A case unfolding in New York has shocked even the most experienced detectives. Five suspects now face murder charges for the brutal, months-long torture and killing of Sam Nordquist, a 24-year-old trans man. The case has ignited national outrage and calls for systemic change.
A Journey That Ended in Unimaginable Suffering
In September 2024, Sam left Minnesota and moved to New York. Friends say he hoped for a fresh start and a more accepting environment. Sadly, that hope turned into horror.
His family last heard from him in January. When weeks passed with no word, they contacted authorities. On February 9, police responded with a welfare check at a lodge in Ontario County, where Sam had been living.
Officers quickly realized something was terribly wrong.
Police Uncover the Unthinkable
Investigators found clear signs of severe abuse at the lodge. Days later, they discovered Sam’s body in a remote field located in another county. The evidence pointed to an extended period of torture.
According to Captain Kelly Swift from New York State Police Troop E, Sam endured repeated physical and psychological abuse between December and early February. Swift emphasized the cruelty of the case, describing it as “a nightmare of sustained violence.”
Meet the Accused: Faces Behind the Charges
Police arrested five individuals, each charged with second-degree murder under depraved indifference:
- Precious Arzuaga
- Jennifer Quijano
- Kyle Sage
- Patrick Goodwin
- Emily Motyka
All five remain in jail without bail. Prosecutors are preparing what could become a landmark case in the state.
Prosecutor Speaks: ‘Beyond Depraved’
District Attorney James Ritts did not hold back during his press conference.
“No human being should have to endure what Sam endured. The circumstances surrounding this case are not just cruel—they’re beyond depraved. It’s the worst our office has ever seen.”
Ritts’ statement resonated across the courtroom and beyond. The level of violence described left many speechless.
Hate Crime Charges Possible
At this stage, officials have not confirmed whether Sam’s gender identity served as a primary motive. However, investigators continue exploring hate crime enhancements. According to sources close to the case, evidence suggests a deliberate and targeted campaign of abuse.
Given the context and Sam’s trans identity, civil rights groups are urging prosecutors to pursue hate crime charges.
A Nation Demands Answers and Action
Across social media, community vigils, and advocacy networks, people are demanding more than just convictions. They want change.
One LGBTQ+ rights organization issued a statement:
“This is not only a tragedy—it’s a call to action. Trans people deserve safety, dignity, and justice. What happened to Sam reflects a society still far from protecting its most vulnerable.”
What Comes Next?
The court will begin preliminary hearings for each suspect in the coming weeks. Prosecutors have signaled their intent to pursue the maximum allowable penalties.
As the investigation continues, forensic teams are analyzing additional evidence, including cell phone records and communication between the suspects.
Authorities encourage anyone with relevant information to come forward.
Who Was Sam Nordquist?
Sam wasn’t just a victim—he was a son, a friend, and a person filled with dreams. Those who knew him describe him as gentle, artistic, and deeply empathetic. His death, however brutal, will not define him. Instead, advocates and loved ones aim to honor his memory by fighting for justice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Sam Nordquist?
He was a 24-year-old trans man from Minnesota who moved to New York and tragically became the victim of prolonged torture and murder.
When was Sam reported missing?
His family filed a missing person report on February 9, 2025, after losing contact in January.
Who has been arrested in connection with his death?
Five individuals: Precious Arzuaga, Jennifer Quijano, Kyle Sage, Patrick Goodwin, and Emily Motyka.
Have authorities confirmed this as a hate crime?
Not officially, but investigators are considering it and collecting evidence related to motive.
What charges are the suspects facing?
All five have been charged with second-degree murder under depraved indifference and are held without bail.
How can I help or support trans communities?
Consider supporting organizations like the Transgender Law Center, Human Rights Campaign, or local LGBTQ+ shelters and advocacy groups.